Kathmandu University Medical Journal (2008), Vol. 6, No. 3, Issue 23, 370-374
Asthma and dental erosion Manuel ST1, Kundabaka M2, Shetty N3, Parolia A1
1Assisstant professor, 2Professor, 3Associate professor, Department of Conservative Dentistry and Endodontotics, Manipal College of Dental Science, Mangalore, India
Abstract
Asthma is a chronic inÀ ammatory condition of the airway, characterised by the presence of airÀ ow obstruction which is variable over short periods of time, or is reversible with treatment. Medication comprises of bronchodilators, corticosteroids and anticholinergic drugs. Most asthma drugs are inhaled using various forms of inhalers or nebulizers. Inhaled drugs must be used regularly. The effects of these drugs on the dentition such as tooth decay and erosion have been a subject of debate among dental practitioners. Asthmatic medications can place the patient at risk of dental erosion by reducing salivary protection against extrinsic or intrinsic acids. Asthmatic individuals are one of the higher risk groups suffering from dental erosion. Therefore patients with bronchial asthma should receive special prophylactic attention. This article presents a case of an asthmatic with dental manifestations and reviews the possible causes and management of the same.
Key words: Asthma, dry powder inhalers, beta-2 agonist, gastro-esophageal reÀ ux, dental erosion.
asthma. The effects of these drugs on the dentition such
The prevalence of asthma has increased steadily
over the latter part of the last century. Currently
as tooth decay and erosion have been a subject of debate
estimates suggest that 300 million people world-wide
suffers from asthma and an additional 100 million may be diagnosed with asthma by 20251. Asthma is a
Review of the literature
chronic inÀ ammatory condition that causes the airways
Inhalers which deliver these medicaments may be used
(bronchi) to produce excess mucus and close, making
up to four times a day over long periods and since
breathing dif¿ cult. It is characterised by the presence of
more than 5% of the population is affected by asthma,
airÀ ow obstruction which is variable over short periods
erosion produced by associated medication could pose
of time, or is reversible with treatment. The aetiology
a signi¿ cant population-wide dental health problem.
of asthma is complex, and multiple environmental and
However the evidence for such an association is unclear.
Although Shaw et al and McDerra et al reported that children with asthma were at an increased risk of
Treatment has two main objectives: ¿ rst, to control
developing erosion 3, 4, 5; few other studies yielded no
and reduce inÀ ammation and, second, to reopen the
clear association between asthma and dental erosion 6.
airways. Drugs that achieve the ¿ rst goal are called anti-inÀ ammatory agents, and those that bring about
Asthmatic medications can place the patient at risk of
the second are called bronchodilators. Many asthma
dental erosion by reducing salivary protection against
sufferers inhale these medications. Medications for
extrinsic or intrinsic acids7 (Table 1).
asthma fall into two categories: Quick relief medication comprises of short acting bronchodilators, systemic corticosteroids and anticholinergic drugs. Long-term control medication includes anti-inÀ ammatory agents, long-acting bronchodilators, and leukotriene modi¿ ers2. Most asthma drugs are inhaled using various forms of inhalers or nebulizers. Inhaled drugs must be used
Correspondence Dr. Manuel S. Thomas
regularly as prescribed and the patient carefully trained
Assist. Prof., Dept of Conservative Dentistry and Endodontotics
in their use in order for them to be effective and safe.
Several studies have examined a possible association
between erosion and inhaled medication used to treat
Saliva is considered to be one of the main neutralizing
erosion. Harding reported that gastro-oesophageal
factors in the pathogenesis of dental erosion. The oral
ux symptoms are more prevalent in asthma
clearance of dietary acid will be related to the rate of
patients compared with control populations, with a
secretion and buffering capacity of saliva8. There is
prevalence of approximately 75%14. Part of the inhaled
newer evidence that medicines taken by dry-power
medication might be swallowed. This may cause minor
inhaler may cause tooth erosion in children by changing
stomach upset or “heartburn,” which can do long-
the mouth’s chemical environment. They reduce the
term damage. The beta 2 adrenoreceptors and drugs
production of saliva, affecting the mouth’s natural
such as Aminophylline and Theophylline can cause
way of maintaining its chemical balance. Ryberg
relaxation of other smooth muscles such as the lower
et al found a lowered secretion rate of whole and
oesophageal sphincter. This relaxation is associated with
parotid saliva, decreased secretion of saliva proteins
gastrooesophageal reÀ ex4. The relationship between
and higher streptococcus mutans counts in asthmatic
gastrointestinal disease and dental erosion has been
subjects treated with beta 2-adrenoceptor agonists
noted by several researchers 15, 16, 17. So, this may also
than in matched healthy controls 9. The effects of the
provide at least a partial explanation of the relationship
beta adrenoceptors on salivary composition and À ow
rate were further investigated by Kargul et al10. They considered the effects of Salbutamol and Fluticasone
Management
proprionate inhalers on plaque and saliva pH in
Proper oral hygiene instructions: Since it has been
asthmatic children aged 6–14 years. The authors found
shown that the dry powder inhalers used for asthma
that pH values decreased in plaque and saliva in the
have an acidic pH, to offset these side effects, the
30 min following inhalation of the drugs. In asthma,
patients should be persuaded to get into the habit
drug-induced xerostomia is dose-dependent. At higher
of rinsing their mouth immediately after using the
bronchodilator concentrations a reduction is seen in
inhaler with neutral pH or basic mouth rinses, such
the natural anti-bacterial compounds and buffering
as liquid antacids, sodium bicarbonate in water,
agents normally found in saliva such as IgA, calcium,
milk or neutral sodium À uoride mouth rinses.
lactoferrin and total protein. Reduced salivary buffering
Patients should also be instructed not to brush their
power makes patients more vulnerable to the erosive
teeth immediately after exposure to acids as it may
action of acids, either extrinsic or intrinsic.
Modi¿ cation of drug delivery system: Another
Anti-asthmatic drugs can cause tooth erosion in children
simple measure to reduce tooth erosion is by using
and the culprit is thought to be the newer dry-powder
a spacer device to deliver the powder. Spacers
inhalers. Dry powder inhalers are convenient and easy to
such as ‘Volumetric’ are clear plastic balloon-
use. They dispense medicine directly to the place where
like devices with a one-way valve. By providing
it is needed, greatly reducing side effects as compared
a spacer between the inhaler and the mouth, the
with medicines taken as pills or tablets. They also
velocity of the powder is reduced, thus reducing
deliver medicine to the troubled site quickly, without
the ferocity of the impact of the powder on the
need for absorption, digestion and circulation. And they
oropharnyx. The time lag in delivery permits more
can deliver long-lasting anti-inÀ ammatory bene¿ ts or
of the propellant to evaporate; hence more particles
short-acting, quick-relief bronchodilation when needed.
No other way of taking asthma drugs is so versatile. The
Increasing the salivary À ow and buffering capacity:
powder versions of preventer therapies e.g. Becotide
Use of sugarless chewing gum to stimulate salivary
and Flixotide and relief bronchodilators e.g. Ventolin
À ow and buffer the oral acids should also be
and Bricanyl, the mainstays of asthma treatment, are
encouraged 18. Experimentally, chewing gum for at
acidic with a pH below 5.5 11, 12. Reports from clinical
least one minute after using an inhaler neutralized
experiments demonstrated a fall in the pH of interdental
the interdental plaque pH10. Adult asthmatics can be
plaque and saliva during the thirty minutes following
advised to use saliva substitutes, sip plain water and
the use of inhaler medication for asthma. Enamel starts
use daily À uoride mouth rinse to compensate for the
to dissolve below pH 5.5. The powder in the puffers can
xerostomia. All age groups of asthmatics should be
erode the tooth enamel when used regularly 13. It is also
made aware of the problem and encouraged to have
possible that there will be an increased consumption of
drinks to compensate for oral dehydration, often drinks with a low pH, which could also cause erosion 4.
Treatment of gastric reÀ ex: The evidence is strong that gastro-oesophageal reÀ ux plays an important
Conditions such as vomiting, heartburn and stomach
role in some patients with asthma. Presumptive
problems were more commonly reported in the asthma
diagnosis by the dentist should lead to appropriate
and erosion groups and were associated with dental
referral for further investigation. Most often it will
be to a gastroenterologist for gastroscopy and 24-
complain of sensitivity to cold food. He also complained
hour measurement of oesophageal pH. Anti-acid
of discoloured restorations in his upper and lower front
drugs have to be prescribed to the patients having
teeth. Patient’s medical history revealed that he is an
asthmatic on medication. He has been suffering from
De¿ nitive treatment: Once the preventive measures
this chronic inÀ ammatory condition since 18 years and
have been instituted, de¿ nitive restoration of the
his asthmatic attacks are triggered by dust. Since then
dentition can begin. Indication for restoration
he has regularly been on medication (table 2).
may include protection of the remaining tooth structure, aesthetic consideration, prevention of
When asked about his oral hygiene habits, it was
dentin sensitivity, severe vertical discrepancies and
understood that the patient brushes his teeth 2 to 3 times
temporomandibular joint dysfunction. Treatment
a day, immediately after the use of the inhaler.
may range from simple to exceedingly complex, depending on the extent of tooth destruction and
Clinical examination revealed saucer shaped loss of
the ability of the masticatory system as a whole to
tooth structure on the labial surface of the teeth 23, 34,
35, 44 and 45. There were also discoloured composite restorations on the labial surface of the teeth 22, 31, 32
Case report
and 33 (Fig 1). Minimal attrition of posterior teeth was
A male patient 43 years of age came to the Department
of Conservative dentistry and Endodontics, with a chief
Table 1: Possible cause for increased incidence of erosion in asthmatics
I) Reduced buffering capacity and salivary À ow rate caused by ȕ 2 agonist
II) Increased exposure of the teeth to acids
Intrinsic source - Gastro-esophageal reÀ ux
Table 2: Medication taken by the patient.
Long term relief medica-tion ( to prevent asth-
matic attacks and control chronic symptoms)
Fig 1: Pre-operative photograph shows saucer shaped Fig 2: Post-operative photograph shows the restoration
loss of tooth structure on the labial surface of
of the erosive lesions and the replacement of
the teeth 23, 34, 35, 44 and 45 and discoloured
discoloured restoration with composite resin.
composite resin restorations on the labial surface of the teeth 22, 31, 32 and 33
Discussion The most probable cause for tooth structure loss in
4. Al-Dlaigan YH, Shaw L, Smith AJ. Is there a
this patient could be due to the brushing of the teeth
relationship between asthma and dental erosion?
immediately after the use of dry powder inhaler. The
A case control study. Int J Paediatr Dent. 2002;
reason for tooth wear also could be supplemented by drug
induced gastritis for which he is taking medication.
The dental status of asthmatic British school
Treatment plan: The patient was instructed to rinse his
children. Paediatric Dentistr.y 1998; 20: 281–7.
mouth with a À uoride mouth wash immediately after the
6. Dugmore CR, Rock WP. Asthma and tooth
use of the inhaler. He was also instructed not to brush
erosion. Is there an association? Int J Paediatr
his teeth as soon as the inhaler is used. The defects
on the labial surfaces of teeth 23, 34, 35, 44 and 45
where restored with composite resin. The discoloured
V, Priest J, Khan F, Harbrow D, Daley TJ.
composite restorations on the labial aspect of the teeth
Dental erosion in asthma: a case-control study
22, 31, 32 and 33 were also replaced (¿ g 2).
from south east Queensland. Aust Dent J. 2002; 47:298-303.
Conclusion
8. Meurman JH, ten Cate JM. Pathogenesis and
Asthmatic individuals are one of the higher risk groups
modifying factors of dental erosion. European
suffering from dental erosion. Therefore patients with
Journal of Oral Sciences. 1996; 104: 199–206.
bronchial asthma should receive special prophylactic attention for the condition.
9. Ryberg M, Moller C, Ericson T. Effect of beta-2
adrenoceptor agonists on saliva proteins and
References
dental caries in asthmatic children. Journal of Dental Research. 1987; 66: 1404–6.
1. Boon AN, Colledge RN, Walker RB. Davidson’s
Principles and Practice of Medicine. In: Sharpe
10. Kargul B, Tanboga I, Ergeneli S, Karakoc F,
MC, Potts SG, editors. Medical Psychiatry.
Dagli E. Inhaler medicament effects on saliva
20th ed. London, UK: Churchill Livingstone
and plaque pH in asthmatic children. Journal of
Clinical Pediatric. Dentistry 1998; 22: 137–40.
11. O’Sullivan EA, Curzon ME. Drug treatments
Current medical diagnosis and treatment-2007.
for asthma may cause erosive tooth damage. Br
46th ed. US: McGraw-Hill Professional; 2006.
3. Shaw L, AL-Dlaigan YH, Smith A. Childhood
12. Randell TL, Donaghue KC, Ambler GR, Cowell
asthma and dental erosion. J Dent Child. 2000;
CT, Fitzgerald DA, VanAsperen P. Safety of
the newer inhaled corticosteroids in childhood asthma. Paediatr Drugs. 2003; 5: 481-504.
13. Tootla R, Toumba KJ, Duggal MS. An evaluation
of the acidogenic potential of asthma inhalers.
gastroesophageal reÀ ux on the oral cavity.
Archives of Oral Biology, 2004; 49: 275-83.
American Journal of Medicine. 1997; 103:
14. Harding SM. Gastroesophageal reÀ ux and
asthma: Insight into the association. Journal of
Allergy and Clinical Immunology. 1999; 104:
dental erosion by professional and individual
prophylactic measures; Eur J Oral Sci. 1996;
15. Sontage SJ. Gastroesophageal reÀ ux and
asthma. American Journal of Medicine. 1997;
Prevention. Part 3: Prevention of tooth wear. Br
16. Bartlett DW, Evans DF, Smith BGN. The
relationship between gastro-oesophageal reÀ ux disease and dental erosion. Journal of Oral Rehabilitation. 1996; 23: 289–297.
Applies To: All HSC Hospitals, CRTC Component(s): UNMH Responsible Department: Clinical Education/Clinical Affairs Title: GPC Range Orders Decision-making for Medications Patient Age Group: ( ) N/A (X ) All Ages ( ) Newborns ( ) Pediatric ( ) Adult POLICY STATEMENT: To maintain the safe, clear and consistent administration of those medications which have been prescribe
The British Journal of Diabetes & Vascular Disease Metformin European Association for the Study of Diabetes, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, September 2007 British Journal of Diabetes & Vascular Disease 2007 7: 247The online version of this article can be found at: can be found at: The British Journal of Diabetes & Vascular Disease Additional services and information fo